Investment crossholdings a Tax Office nightmareIan McIlwraith
February 7, 2012
Australia's listed investment groups, presiding over a pool of $16 billion of other people's money, now have almost $800 million invested in one another.
[Like 5% is a worry? Must be a slow news day - Judd]When your existence is all about chasing yield, it is probably inevitable that you buy shares in like-minded companies (or the ''diversified financials'' sector as they are classed by index-hugging investors) - but it is looking decidedly ''clubby''.
For Insider, it has the feel of one of M.C.Escher's famous artworks: Australian Foundation Investment Co has $30 million in Diversified United Investment Corp, which owns $12 million in Washington H. Soul Pattinson, which owns $106 million of Milton Corp, which has $1 million in Argo Investments, which has $112 million in Australian United Investment Co … you get the picture.
Advertisement: Story continues below
And just think what it must be like at dividend payment time as the order is reversed - AUI sends a cheque to Argo, which sends one to Milton, which sends one to Soul Patts etc. Best of luck to Michael D'Ascenzo and the Tax Office team trying to work out who paid the tax on all those franked dividends flying around.
Argo Investments, which reported its half-year results yesterday, is (sort of) the odd one out because it has no real stablemates.
It makes up for that by having more than $280 million of its near $4 billion portfolio parked in like-minded groups. Its largest stake is in Milton Cor, where it has $130 million of stock, followed by the AUI stake. Those two stakes are among Argo's 10 largest equities holdings. It also has more than $30 million in DUI.
By way of comparison, it has a minuscule holding in fellow Adelaide company Santos, which although valued by the market at $13 billion, commands just $55 million of Argo's money, or 1.6 per cent of the total portfolio.
Strangely, though, none of the other investment companies seem to return the favour. Argo's biggest shareholder has less than 1 per cent of issued capital, three out of five of its biggest investors are related to the deputy chairman and one-time stock-picking executive director, Robert Rich.
Milton is itself a member of a very tight circle of companies run by Sydney's Millner family. Robert Millner last year enjoyed some unwelcome publicity as institutional shareholders in members of his group, that apart from Milton includes Washington H. Soul Pattinson and Brickworks, tried to force a break-up of the interlinked shareholdings to crystallise gains.
There is no denying that the Millner-run companies have been tidy performers over the years; it is just that fund managers (themselves under pressure to justify their fees in shabby equities markets) reckon there is considerable value that can be unlocked.
The other two big investment groups, both of which grew out of two of Melbourne's most conservative stockbroking firms - JB Were and Potter Partners - also have healthy stakes in other members of their families.
With DUI and AUI, which grew out of the late Sir Ian Potter's cash accumulating skills (and retains many a Potter relative on its register), the former has $30 million of its stock owned by the latter.
The once-were warriors of investment Australian Foundation owns about $32 million of the spin-out Djerriwarrh Investments and another $16 million in Mirrabooka. Djerriwarrh also has $8.6 million in Mirrabooka.
Read more:
http://www.theage.com.au/business/inves ... z1lfE4Cjfg